10 Recently Sold & Off-Market Properties in New York

Ever wonder what slips through the real estate cracks in a bustling market like New York? We’re pulling back the curtain on 10 properties that have recently sold or were negotiated off-market, offering a rare glimpse into the city’s dynamic property landscape.

Prime Commercial Property | $399,500

180 Main Street, Cortland, NY
Listing agent: Philip Henry

Prime commercial property located at the intersection of Main and Union Streets in the Cortland City central business district. It offers four fully rented commercial locations and two rented 2-bedroom apartments.

 

Size: 7,599 sf

 

Price: $399,500

 

Listing details: Commercial spaces and monthly rents are: 3,500 s/f convenience store ($1,350), 800 s/f corner location shop ($750), 800 s/f Union Street side location hair salon with full kitchen, full bathroom, and laundry room ($525), and 800 s/f heated warehouse space with 9’ x 10’ overhead door ($300).

 

Contact: Philip Henry, SVR Realty LLC, +1 607-423-3175

For Residential Development! | $449,995

3360 Chili Avenue, Chili, NY
Listing agent: Bob Malone

Available for residential development. 13.2 Acres, utilities available at street.

 

Size: 13.2 acres

 

Price: $449,995

 

Contact: Bob Malone, Keller Williams Realty, +1 585.733.7729

Wonderful To Meet You! | $405,000 (Sold)

14 Blue Heron Dr, Rochester, NY
Listing agent: Carli Ebbs

SOLD! Nestled on a peaceful cul-de-sac within the Spencerport school district. Enjoy breathtaking water views while you sit back and relax on the spacious deck or in the pool. This 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom masterpiece offers the perfect blend of elegance and tranquility.

 

Size: 2,887 sf

 

Price: $405,000 (Sold)

 

Listing details: The chef’s kitchen is a culinary delight, featuring granite counter tops, stainless steel appliances, and a large center island. Fully finished basement includes a dedicated workout room, pool table, built-in wet bar, full bathroom, built in sauna and egress to the garage. Come check out recent updates done during our open house Friday 11/10 3-5 PM

 

Contact: Carli Ebbs, Berkshire Hathaway Home Services, +1 585.313.8258

Skunks Misery Rd | $3,100,000

Skunks Misery Rd, Millerton, NY
Listing agent: Larry Havens & Robert Dunlop

Immerse yourself in the allure of 207.73 acres of picturesque land, thoughtfully combined from two lots to form an exceptional estate expanse. This captivating property, nestled within an esteemed estate area, offers a harmonious blend of lush woodlands, inviting meadows, tranquil ponds, babbling streams, and captivating vistas.

 

Size: 207 acres

 

Price: $3,100,000

 

Listing details: The location is truly unparalleled, presenting an outstanding opportunity to build your dreams. Positioned at the pinnacle of desirability, this prime location boasts convenience and connectivity. A mere 10-minute drive brings you to the Metro-North train station, ensuring effortless access to the city.

 

Contact: Larry Havens & Robert Dunlop, Havens Real Estate, +1 845-453-5679, 845-325-2912

Skunks Misery Rd | $1,600,000

Skunks Misery Rd, Millerton, NY
Listing agent: Larry Havens & Robert Dunlop

Discover the epitome of natural beauty in this exquisite land nestled within an exclusive estate area! A harmonious blend of lush woods, expansive meadows, serene ponds, babbling streams, and breathtaking vistas await you. Perfectly positioned, this prime location offers convenience at its finest – just a short 10- minute drive to the metro-north Train station, connecting you to city adventures.

 

Size: 101 acres

 

Price: $$1,600,000

 

Listing details: Additionally, relish the charm of the trendy village of Millerton, a mere 5- minute journey away, with its vibrant culture and chic amenities. Whether you’re yearning for an idyllic retreat or envisioning the perfect canvas to build your dream abode, this remarkable land offers an unparalleled opportunity. Act now to seize this rare gem and embrace a life of tranquility and elegance.

 

Contact: Larry Havens & Robert Dunlop, Havens Real Estate, +1 845-453-5679, 845-325-2912

Listing agent: Linda Hirvonen

An idyllic country setting with 17 acres nestled right next to upscale suburbia and within 10 minutes of Cornell University, downtown Ithaca and beautiful Cayuga Lake. Built in 1840, this classic upstate NY farmhouse with Greek Revival elements has three bedrooms and 4 full baths, gracious entry, eat-in kitchen, den, family room or main floor bedroom and a sunroom for morning coffee and bird watching.

 

Size:   sf

 

Price: Contact for pricing

 

Listing details: The detached garage includes a 2 bedroom apartment and the grounds include a charming babbling brook, a rose garden with a fountain, a large pond that attracts geese and deer year round and lots of unspoiled acres to roam, plant gardens, raise chickens or develop.

 

Contact: Linda Hirvonen, Warren Real Estate, +1 607-592-3665

150 Sackett Lake Road | $3,250,000

150 Sackett Lake Rd, Monticello, NY
Listing agent: Peter H. Malone & John “Johnny C” Coladonato

• Mostly level parcel zoned SR (Suburban Residential Development). • Property previously approved (in 2005) for 307-unit cluster housing development. Approvals have since expired; same zoning regulations still in place. • Large portion of site already cleared.

 

Size: 120 acres

 

Price: $3,250,000

 

Listing details: Site has potential access to city water & sewer. • Within 5 miles Resorts World Casino, Monticello Motor Club, Monticello Raceway, Kartrite Hotel & Water Park and the Center for Discovery

 

Contact: Peter H. Malone & John “Johnny C” Coladonato, Pyramid Brokerage Company, +1 914.213.2863, 845.258.8424

51 Spring St | Contact for pricing

51 Spring St, Keeseville, NY
Listing agent: Terry Jandreau

In Keeseville’s Hamlet, discover this charming 3,362 sq ft home on 0.9 acres. Features spacious entry foyer, hardwood floors, knotty pine walls, and fireplace.

 

Size: 3,362 sf

 

Price: Contact for pricing

 

Listing details:  Enjoy natural light, private patio, and ample storage. With municipal water/sewer, priced at $399,000. Ideal for family living or entertaining. Your new home awaits!

 

Contact: Terry Jandreau, Davidson Real Estate Group, +1 518-281-8977

A Slice Of Heaven | $489,000

796 Oswegatchie Trl, Star Lake, NY
Listing agent: Kim Moffitt

Are you looking for your own slice of heaven? How does peace, tranquility and 127 acres nestled in the foothills of the Adirondack Park sound? May- be you are an outdoor enthusiast? This beautiful property will take your breath away! The Five Ponds Wilderness Area Range runs through the property with a plateau at the summit where you can enjoy panoramic views and wildlife.

 

Size: 1,416 sf

 

Price: $489,000

 

Listing details: Perhaps a perfect place for a future small cabin? There’s even a pond at the rear of the property! Besides the property itself, there’s a large 3 bedroom/1 bathroom ranch, with an extra bonus room that is currently being used as an office. Upon entering the home you are greeted with a size able living room with a large front window that boasts panoramic views and the perfect frame for gorgeous sunsets.

 

Contact: Kim Moffitt, Lets Move Realty, +1 315.705.1225

Spectacular Home | SOLD

39 Constitution Ave, Buffalo, NY
Listing agent: Musa Alamari

SOLD! Pride of ownership shines throughout this 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath, 4 car garage, spacious, immaculate home! The grand 2-story entryway w/ a refinished wooden spiral staircase & a new composite 4 x 5 window & the master bedroom w/ a walk-in closet, Berber carpet & double vanity, ceramic floor bathroom are impressive features.

 

Size: 2,276 sf

 

Price: SOLD

 

Listing details: No expense was spared on the upgrades, including diamond dust finished hardwood floors & crown molding in the DR, FR & LR w/ a marble threshold, new steel porcelain tubs, new gas fireplace & wooden mantle to name a few. The kitchen, w/ a new dishwasher, stove & microwave oven complimented by granite counter tops & a double pantry is a perfect place for hosting gatherings.

 

Contact: Musa Alamari, Howard Hanna Real Estate Services, +1 716-53-33368