Big Bluff, Bellport’s Coastal Treasure

Presented by
Mark Petheram & Leonardo Figueredo
of Old Purchase properties

Price: $8,750,000

Location: 14 Peathole Lane, Bellport Village, NY 11713

Nestled on Bellport Bay in the historic village of Bellport, Big Bluff is a property that represents the pinnacle of waterfront living. Positioned at 14 Peathole Lane, this estate is a rare opportunity to immerse oneself in an exclusive lifestyle. With stunning views of the bay, an array of impeccable amenities, and a location steeped in charm, it exemplifies the unique appeal of Bellport.

Bellport is considered by many to be the Hamptons’ understated counterpart, offering an elegant respite without the influx of summer crowds. Located just 60 miles from New York City, this quaint village combines timeless sophistication with coastal charm. Picturesque shops and thriving art galleries line its streets, while the Bellport Country Club offers golfing and tennis in a refined setting. Bellport residents can access unique amenities such as a private ferry leading to Ho-Hum Beach on Fire Island, a peaceful sanctuary that enhances the allure of this coastal community.

Big Bluff itself is an unparalleled retreat, blending impeccable craftsmanship with thoughtful design. Encompassing 5,000 square feet, the five-bedroom, four-bathroom residence is sited on a lush one-acre property with 172 feet of private waterfront. Its classic New England architectural style, with shingles and expansive windows, complements its stunning natural surroundings.

Inside, the home is an embodiment of relaxed elegance. The living room is a showpiece, boasting floor-to-ceiling windows, a wood-burning fireplace, and an abundance of natural light that maximizes the sweeping water views. The kitchen, set within the home’s tower, is designed for both function and style, with custom wood cabinetry, high-end appliances such as a Viking range and Sub-Zero refrigerator, and a layout that embraces its waterfront setting. Spacious dining and entertainment areas continue to highlight the home’s seamless connection to the bay, making this a space for both grand gatherings and tranquil mornings.

The primary bedroom suite is a serene retreat, with uninterrupted vistas of the Great South Bay and a spa-like en-suite bath, complete with a luxurious soaking tub. The lower level extends the home’s appeal, offering a fitness area, steam shower, and a media room or lounge that connects directly to the outdoor spaces.

The estate’s exterior is equally breathtaking, designed to maximize its waterfront location. Outdoor amenities include a heated 16’x50’ swimming pool surrounded by manicured gardens, a private tennis court with an elevated viewing deck, and multiple entertainment spaces. Features like a Kalamazoo grill, pizza oven, and open-air dining area make it ideal for hosting gatherings. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the private dock and the easy access to the bay.

The Bellport market continues to attract discerning buyers, with waterfront homes in high demand. The increasing trend of buyers investing over $6 million to acquire and rebuild waterfront properties highlights the lasting value of this community. Big Bluff stands out as a prime example of Bellport’s appeal, offering a move-in-ready home or a long-term investment opportunity.

Listed at $8.75 million, Big Bluff’s combination of location, design, and exclusivity makes it one of Long Island’s most remarkable properties. It captures the essence of Bellport’s unique lifestyle and remains a testament to the enduring charm of waterfront living.