9 Indiana Properties for Sale Under $500K

Who says affordable homes can’t be charming? Indiana offers a variety of properties blending beauty and budget. These nine homes, all under $500K, are perfect for settling into your dream home.

Luxurious Lifestyle | $430,000

2624 Congress St, Carmel, IN
Listing Agent: Nathan Pfahler

Are you ready for a LUXURY Maintenance Free type of lifestyle? Then you are ready for this beautiful townhome in The Village of West Clay! This stunning home was designed for entertaining! Friends and family alike will love the lower level bar area- complete with a lounge area and full bath (can also double as a guest suite). The “main” level of the townhome features a large sitting room with built-in bookshelves, and a well-designed/ functional chef-friendly kitchen open to the dining area and great room. Great room has a corner gas fireplace!

 

Size: 2,418 sf

 

Price: $430,000

 

Listing details: On the upper level there are 2 master suites! The primary features a large bathroom with double sinks, and walk- in tiled shower. The secondary features a tub/shower style bathroom and extra large walk-in closet! Well appointed laundry room finishes off this level. Off the dining area is a large deck for exterior entertaining, or just for a cup of morning coffee or evening glass of wine! Neighborhood features numerous greenspaces, 3 beautiful pool areas, pickleball AND tennis courts, as well fitness facilities! Several great restaurants, shops, library and doctor offices a short distance away! Make this townhouse your HOME today!

 

Contact: Nathan Pfahler, Weichert Realtors, +1 317.450.1094

9352 Golden Oaks W| $270,000

9352 Golden Oaks W, Indianapolis, IN
Listing Agent: Mary Boustani

This spacious 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. You will enjoy the modern updates to the kitchen, featuring new cabinets, countertops, and appliances. The updated lighting in the main living areas adds a touch of sophistication.

 

Size: 1,633 sf

 

Price: $270,000

 

Listing details: The spacious great room with a vaulted ceiling, dining room with skylight, and breakfast nook off the kitchen with Laundry area create a welcoming and open- concept living space. Single-level living makes this home ideal for those who prefer easy accessibility. The low-maintenance lifestyle provided by the HOA, which takes care of all lawncare and exterior building maintenance. Amenities like a swimming pool and tennis court offer opportunities for recreation and socializing. Conveniently located near shopping, dining and healthcare, this home offers easy access to everything you need.

 

Contact: Mary Boustani, Home Partners, +1 317.565.3220

Newly Remodeled Ranch | $319,000

7801 Dartmouth Road, Indianapolis, IN
Listing Agent: Yaima Medina

Newly remodeled (2023) ranch-style brick home. The home features 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. New luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, new ceramic tile in the bathrooms, and newer carpet in the master bedroom. Spacious open kitchen with new cabinets and granite countertop.

 

Size: 1,665 sf

 

Price: $319,000

 

Listing details: Newer high quality appliances. Cozy, good functioning fireplace. Spacious, fenced-in, and relaxing wooded backyard, with a large wood deck and large shed for storage or a workshop. The home has a large 2-car garage with plenty of space for storage. Close to parks, shopping and entertainment. Short drive to Indianapolis Downtown, Broad Ripple, Carmel.

 

Contact: Yaima Medina, Central Indiana Property, +1 317.908.2916

207 Blue Ridge Road | $449,900

207 Blue Ridge Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Listing Agent: Joe Sprunger

Welcome to 207 Blue Ridge Rd, a beautifully updated historical Colonial farmhouse built in 1929, located in the highly sought-after Butler-Tarkington neighborhood of Indianapolis. This charming residence seamlessly blends classic elegance with modern amenities, offering a spacious and stylish living environment.

 

Size: 2,493 sf

 

Price: $449,900

 

Listing details: The main bedroom features a private balcony, perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or evening relaxation. The home boasts a new roof, a newly finished basement, and the charm of hardwoods and curved archways. Other updates include new top of the line HVAC with HEPA, new Anderson Renewal Front Door, new water softener system, new gutter guards, smart-home features including locks, cameras and a electric car charging port.

 

Contact: Joe Sprunger, The Tucker Realtors , +1 317-491-4424

Quaker Built Farmhouse |$443,500

7540 S Mooresville Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Listing Agent: Angi Oakes

A beautifully preserved Quaker-built farmhouse that seamlessly blends historic charm with modern luxury. Built in 1827, this stunning residence sits on 1.4 picturesque acres, offering a unique slice of history with all the comforts of today. Step inside to discover a home thoughtfully updated with modern amenities. The spacious kitchen features granite countertops and brand-new appliances, perfect for culinary enthusiasts.

 

Size: 4,698 sf

 

Price: $443,500

 

Listing details: The expansive rec room offers endless possibilities, whether you envision it as a short-term rental, an in-law suite, or your ultimate entertainment space. The property boasts an attached oversized 2-car garage, previously home to 2 cars and a hot tub, now a blank canvas awaiting your personal touch. With ample space for hobbies, storage, or additional recreational activities, the garage adds to the home’s versatility.

 

Contact: Angi Oakes, Berkshire Hathaway,  +1 317.514.4695

6140 N 500 Rd E | $199,900

6140 N 500 Rd E, Montpelier, IN
Listing Agent: Kathy Casterline

country home! Beautiful setting and located near shopping, library and Civic Center. It has 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. The eat in kitchen has a decorative stone wall and seat by the patio doors.

 

Size: 1,758 sf

 

Price: $199,900

 

Listing details: A stone wall in the family room has a wood burning stove. This home has a very nice floor plan and seems to be a solid home. The windows and well were replaced in the last couple of years. It does need some TLC as the previous owners were smokers.

 

Contact: Kathy Casterline, Neff Sales & Development, +1 765.348.7411

10612 Regis Ct | $349,500

10612 Regis Ct, Indianapolis, IN
Listing Agent: Allie Harbor

Privately situated in cul-de-sac with beautiful landscaping, fenced rear yard, extended wood deck with pergola & wooded common back area for privacy & no neighbors behind. Many features include: 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 full baths & 2 half baths, new vinyl planking flooring throughout main level, inviting entry, formal living room, open kitchen with plenty of cabinetry, new SS appliances, pantry, back-splash PLUS separate formal dining room w/ crown molding, newly painted family room with wood-burning fireplace, bonus room on main level that can be used as office/den with built in book shelves, laundry room w/ wash tub & storage cabinets.

 

Size: 3,636 sf

 

Price: $349,500

 

Listing details: Privately situated in cul-de-sac with beautiful landscaping, fenced rear yard, extended wood deck with pergola & wooded common back area for privacy & no neighbors behind. Many features include: 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 full baths & 2 half baths, new vinyl planking flooring throughout main level, inviting entry, formal living room, open kitchen with plenty of cabinetry, new SS appliances, pantry, back-splash PLUS separate formal dining room w/ crown molding, newly painted family room with wood-burning fireplace, bonus room on main level that can be used as office/den with built in book shelves, laundry room w/ wash tub & storage cabinets.

 

Contact: Allie Harbor. Keller Williams Realty, +1 317.909.4020

0 South 600 E | $209,900

0 South 600 E, Lagro, IN
Listing Agent: Kristi Lundquist

16.5-acre site with 6.5 acres of pasture and 10 acres of woods, ideal for building, recreation, hunting, or horses.

 

Size: 17 acres

 

Price: $209,900

 

Listing details: Minutes from Salamonie Reservoir, forest, fishing, and horse-riding trails.

 

Contact: Kristi Lundquist, Lindquist Appraisals & Real Estate, +1 260.571.4652

807 Division St |$289,500

807 Division St, La Porte, IN
Listing Agent: Betty Daniel-Lanie

ALL NEW from top to bottom. Second story completely replaced on this traditional 2 story 3 bedroom, totally updated home.

 

Size: 1,456 sf

 

Price: $289,500

 

Listing Details: All new kitchen and appliances as well, open concept living/dining room areas. Main floor laundry. Upstairs offers 3 bedrooms,large walk-in closet in masterbedroom with adjacent bath.

 

Contact: Betty Daniel-Lanie, Mc Colly Real Estate, +1 219.716.4481