8 Sold or Off-Market Homes in New York & Puerto Rico

Missed out on these gems? These 8 sold or off-market homes in New York and Puerto Rico offered a rare blend of elegance, location, and lifestyle that quickly captured the market’s attention.

Listing Agent : Carmen Medina

The beautiful city of Cidra, in the central region of the island of Puerto Rico, is rich in history. The origin of its name is tied to the abundance of citron trees, known as “cidra” in Spanish, which are prevalent in the area. Cidra, also known as “The Town of the Eternal Spring” due to its pleasant climate is surrounded by mountains and scenic landscapes.

 

Size: 1,155 sf

 

Price: Contact for pricing

 

Listing details: Key attractions are: Lake Cidra, a manmade reservoir ideal for fishing and boating, and the town’s charming plaza, that features a traditional catholic church while balancing its past and embracing modern development with restaurants and contemporary structures. Discover the epitome of luxurious living in Sabanera, a community that blends the mountain greens, the tropical flora, and sidewalks beside the lakes. There you will find this stunning 3-bedroom residence, easily convertible to 4 bedrooms.

 

Contact: Carmen Medina, Casa Magnifica Real Estate , + 1 787.363.5945

300 Lafayette Avenue |$1,999,999 (Sold)

300 Lafayette Avenue Clinton Hill, Brooklyn, NY
Listing Agent : Malcolm Louis Adams

Missed out on these gems? These 8 sold or off-market homes in New York and Puerto Rico offered a rare blend of elegance.

 

Size: 2,631 sf

 

Price: $1,999,999 (Sold)

 

Listing details: Location, and lifestyle that quickly captured the market’s attention.

 

Contact: Malcolm Louis Adams, Compass , +1 917.972.6166

4482 Boston Post Road | $2,350,000 (Sold)

4482 Boston Post Road, Pelham, NY
Listing Agent : Marc Schaeffer

SOLD! Welcome to the lovely Westchester neighborhood of Pelham Manor and to this 2018 custom built 4,500+ sq ft home on a lush 1/2 acre has all the modern features. Privacy is paramount as you enter through an automatic-gated driveway to a court with parking for 8+ cars, with mature privacy trees on all sides of the property.

 

Size: 4,495 sf

 

Price: $2,350,000 (Sold)

 

Listing details: Designed flawlessly with wonderful natural light, hardwood floors and high ceilings throughout. As you enter through the foyer, you will find the perfect dining room and living room with gas fireplace.

 

Contact: Marc Schaeffer, Salmon Real Estate , +1 917.885.9698

17 Hays Hill Rd|$1,395,000 (Sold)

17 Hays Hill Rd, Pleasantville, NY
Listing Agent : Loretta Chiavetta

SOLD! Looking to live in a community where you will make lifelong friends? In a house that is located in the quaint Village of Pleasantville? Your search is over! This five BR Center Hall Colonial, w/two story entry has it all!The rocking chair porch welcomes you into this special home. It is stately, yet warm & inviting. Spacious, but it feels like home

 

Size: 3,965 sf

 

Price: $1,395,000 (Sold)

 

Listing details: Lovely formal living & dining room w/crown moulding & wood floors. EIK w/custom cabinetry, oversized center island, stainless steel appliances & the east facing windows lets the morning light stream in! Family room w/fireplace and a first floor office w/built-in desk & shelves makes working from home a breeze!The primary en-suite offers a large bedroom w/walk in closets & a five piece full bath.

 

Contact: Loretta Chiavetta, Coldwell Banker, +1 914.434.1864

561 Bolton Avenue | $999,999 (Sold)

561 Bolton Avenue, Bronx, NY
Listing Agent : Nancy Rondon

SOLD! Introducing a beautiful multi two family home in Clason Point perfect for an investor or a large family seeking ample space and versatility. This property features two expansive three-bedroom units, one includes a lovely balcony. Each unit includes a large dining room, wood floors and generous living space, ensuring comfort and functionality for all residents.

 

Size: 3,532 sf

 

Price: $999,999 (Sold)

 

Listing details: Additionally, there is a renovated recreation room and finished renovated basement which offer countless possibilities and additional living space. For added convenience, the home includes a large garage and driveway providing ample parking options.

 

Contact: Nancy Rondon, RE/MAX, +1 917.837.0724

Village Of Sag Harbor ! | $1,683,000

148 Suffolk Street, Sag Harbor, NY
Listing Agent : Phyllis J. Wolkoff

SOLD! Handsome traditional Cape Located on a lovely tree lined street. Minutes from the historic whaling Village of Sag Harbor. Three full bedrooms with 2 full baths. Large, comfortable living room with fireplace. Dining room and fully accommodated kitchen, central air and detached one car garage.

 

Size: 1,674 sf

 

Price: $1,683,000

 

Listing details: Other amenities are an outdoor shower, rear patio and basement on a .56 acre lot. Room for pool.

 

Contact: Phyllis J. Wolkoff, Hampton Villas Realty, +1 631.374.3369

188 Trout Brook Road | $569,000

188 Trout Brook Road, Fremont Center, NY
Listing Agent : Philip Eggleton

LAKE MUSKODAY WATERFRONT Nestled on 177 feet of maintained waterfront, this property offers the perfect blend of comfort and natural beauty. Situated on just over a half-acre it’s an ideal setting for outdoor enthusiasts and those seeking tranquility.

 

Size: 1,440 sf

 

Price: $569,000

 

Listing details: Log-Sided Cabin with Modern Comforts- Step into a charming ten-year-old log-sided cabin featuring expansive decking that invites you to unwind. Whether under the shade of a covered area or basking in the open sun, the decking provides a perfect spot to enjoy the views.

 

Contact: Philip Eggleton, Eagle River Realty, +1 845.665.9521

11 Sunnyside Avenue | $4,995,000

11 Sunnyside Avenue, Shelter Island, NY
Listing Agent : CeeJackTeam

Sited on one of the highest elevations in Shelter Island Heights & within easy reach of the island’s most coveted points of interest, this exquisitely imagined 4-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom brand-new residence on 2 quiet acres offers resort-style luxury living in an oasis of masterful design.

 

Size: 4,000 sf

 

Price: $4,995,000

 

Listing details : A creation of WE+ Architecture & Design, anticipated completion April 2025. The expansive living areas are elegant and spacious, offering ideal settings for both relaxation and entertainment. A state-of-the-art chef’s kitchen features high-end appliances, custom cabinetry, and ample space for culinary pursuits.

 

Contact: CeeJackTeam, Compass , +1 516.383.2011