7 Timeless Historic Homes for Sale in Indiana & Ohio

Get into this sophisticated, mid-century modern home, just steps from the Notre Dame campus Michiana! Hidden away on a quiet, naturesque dead- end street with a view of “Touchdown Jesus” from your front yard and a backyard deck overlooking a park-like setting on an oversized, manicured lot, this is one you won’t want to miss! Highlights include: 3 bed, 1.5 bath, 2,416 sq. ft. ranch, cement kitchen countertops, laundry chute, a custom built torii inspired Japanese gate, large fire pit, vintage street lamp, .74 manicured wooded acres, vegetable garden, partially fenced yard (great for pets), 2 storage sheds, nature paths, hot tub platform off the deck, 3 car tandem attached garage with keypad entry, insulated garage door, newer roof & AC, built in bookshelves, pool table and bar in the partially finished basement, built-in bunk beds, a cedar closet, utility sink, 2 workbenches, 200 amp. electric, and new sliding patio door and front storm door.

Size: 2,416 sf

Price: $549,000

Listing details: This property is an active gameday rental and great investment opportunity that generates $2,000-$6,500 over 2-day weekends. The possibilities are endless! Get inspired Michiana! This is a real charmer, that won’t last!

Contact: Kyra Hammett, Inspired Homes, +1 202408320

Beautiful 4-bed home in Mexico, IN with modern upgrades (2020-2024):

Size: 1,352 sf

Price: $229,000

Listing details: new siding, windows, doors, patio, kitchen with granite counters, marble baths, new flooring, HVAC, exterior lighting, and hot tub wiring.

Contact: Deedee Richards, D.R Indiana Realty LLC, +1 202420373

Welcome to Larchmere and this wonderfully remodeled duplex! Larchmere a historic neighborhood comprising approximately 10 blocks and despite its modest size, this district offers a wide array of amenities, including eclectic shops, galleries, antique stores, historic restaurants, and bakeries.

Size: 2,479 sf

Price: $249,900

Listing details: 

Contact: Tony Parra, Epique Realty, +1 5050448

Step into a piece of history with this charming residence built in 1899, exuding the timeless elegance of the turn of the century! One family owner.

Size: 2,678 sf

Price: $265,000

Listing details: Beautiful original hardwood floors and intricate woodwork throughout, every corner of this home tells a story of craftsmanship & heritage.

Contact: Megan Martini, Burgan Real State, +1 5033947

Charming lake front Colonial home situated on Lake Erie with 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths. Living room has a gas fireplace that opens to the dining room. The kitchen has an eat-in breakfast nook that overlooks the lake and has been tastefully updated with newer stainless steel appliances. The flow of the kitchen is a chef’s delight.

Size: 1,403 sf

Price: $450,000

Listing details:  Basement is partially finished with laundry room, storage room, full bath and an additional bedroom. There is an 28’x12’ upper deck that has spectacular views and the lower deck is 28’x12’ with wrought iron railings. This is lake living with incredible views with the erosion control already done for you. A one-car garage and extra driveway round out this home to make it a truly desirable place to live or use as a great investment opportunity for AirBnb rentals.

Contact: Jennifer Bartone, Harbor Realty, +1 5022116

Meticulously restored and updated. This home has all the charm of a century home but all the amenities of a new built. Outdoor entertaining spaces are the two decks, firepit patio, covered porches and 3/4 acre pond. Sand beach, Windmill aerator for pond. New side deck overlooking pond. New septic tank.

Size: 2,764 sf

Price: $595,000

Listing details: Two barns, 44 x44 and steel pole building 105 x60. Buildings add plenty of space for equipment, toys, cars and trucks. Owner has wood working shop in the detached garage.

Contact: Rebecca Neville, Century 21 Sunway Realty LCC., +1 6114573

Situated on 3.5 acres along the Bratenahl coast of Lake Erie, this gilded-age grande dame underwent an extensive year-long transformation where the greatest of care was taken to bring the home into the 21st century. From the newly built bluestone patio and pool to the meticulously restored original door hardware, no detail was overlooked in perfecting this exquisite property. The grand front entry opens into an exquisite entrance hall where the full grandeur of the home is revealed. A testament to the craftsmanship of a bygone era, each wall is a work of art adorned with intricate carvings, a symphony of imported walnut and oak. Spectacular cut glass leaded windows, a hallmark of the first floor, cast prismatic light into the rooms, creating an ever-changing interplay of color and shadow. The grand dining room, equally impressive, boasts another fireplace and accordion doors that open into a breathtaking sunroom with polished marble floors and a stunning leaded amber glass skylight. Outside, a stone terrace steps down to the wet set bluestone patio and heated pool with a view of the lake and exquisite grounds beyond. A state-of-the-art Control4 smart home system has been seamlessly integrated, providing convenience and control at the touch of a button.

Size: 21,140 sf

Price: $6,990,000

Listing details: Nearly every element of the home has been replaced or restored; please see the supplements for a full list of property improvements. All bedroom suites have been luxuriously equipped and can be found on the second floor. The third floor and lower level have been incredibly reimagined as entertaining areas for modern living. The original ballroom has been repurposed as a modern game room and home theater, and the lower level now functions as a private playground complete with a billiards room, a poker area, a bar with a temperature controlled wine cellar and tasting room, and a fitness center with a sauna. The original gate house has been beautifully restored into a 2-bedroom guest cottage.

Contact: Nick Zawitz & David Ayers& Rick Wesselhoff, The Agency Cleaveland Northcoast, +15041477