7 New York Homes for Sale Under $500K

Unlock the door to your new home with these seven New York properties for sale under $500K, each offering unique features and the chance to thrive in one of the world’s most exciting cities.

987 State Route 222| $469,900

987 State Route 222, Cortland, NY
Listing Agent: Julie Littlefield

Explore this unique property, a converted barn that combines business potential with family living. The home features 4 bedrooms, 4 baths, 3 woodstoves, a kitchen with new stainless steel sink and countertops, wide plank floors, and barn siding in many rooms. The primary loft suite includes a sauna and private deck overlooking a large koi pond.

 

Size: 5,704 sf

 

Price: $469,900

 

Listing details: The lower level, once a veterinary office, offers a reception area, exam rooms, a kennel room, storage rooms, a workshop, and more, all heated and plumbed, providing endless possibilities. Outside, find 13 acres with pastures, woods, walking trails, a creek, two garages, and a barn with stalls.

 

Contact: Julie Littlefield, Howard & Hanna Real Estate, +1 518.323.5855

Nota Queen Anne Victorian | $339,500

400 Alexander St, Rochester, NY
Listing Agent: Bob Wagner

Don’t miss this extraordinary NOTA Queen Anne Victorian home, located in the very desirable Neighborhood of the Arts close to cafes, restaurants, shops and museums. The property borders Rochester’s East End and is minutes from the University of Rochester/Strong. This 5 bedroom 2 full bath home features a stunning front porch and entry hall, open floor plan, hardwood floors, and magnificent stained glass and original chestnut molding throughout. Other highlights include a new retro style kitchen with granite tops, new stainless appliances, 2 deco inspired full baths and a European style cafe side walkway.

 

Size: 2,692 sf

 

Price: $339,500

 

Listing details: There is excellent parking adjacent to a huge park like yard with a brand new studio/garden shed. This home features a newer tear off roof, new furnace, new 200 amp electric, new sewer line and hot water tank. MLS # R1560926 Open House 9/3/24 from 4:00 PM-6:00 PM Delayed Negotiations scheduled for 9/4/24 at 5:00 PM

 

Contact: Bob Wagner, Bob Wagner Real Estate, +1 585.455.3356

Listing Agent: Heather Davala

This meticulously constructed 1969 ranch is on the market for the first time since its completion. The house is surrounded by perennial gardens and the property boasts a stunning private backyard set on 3.30 acres. Inside, the retro / period-style home features a thoughtful layout with living areas on the left and private quarters on the right, separated by a handmade pocket door. Attention to detail is evident in every room.

 

Size: 1,545 sf

 

Price: $385,000

 

Listing details: Three bedrooms and two and a half baths service the house nicely. A kitchen nook is off the back of the home which allows you access to the back deck for outdoor dining. Downstairs, there is a full walk out basement with endless possibilities for a work shop, play room, or additional living space.

 

Contact: Heather Davala, Davala Real Estate, +1 518.605.6380

4359 State Route 3 | $230,000

4359 State Route 3, Redford, NY
Listing Agent: Garrett Hemingway

If you are looking for riverside relaxation, look no further. This home features and oversized 1.5 acre lot on the Saranac river. Private beach adds to this beautiful property. Enjoy waterfront views from any one of the three decks, all built with durable tree composite material.

 

Size: 1,220 sf

 

Price: $230,000

Contact: Garrett Hemingway, Hemingway Realty, +1 518.637.5360

376 Pine Hill Road | $249,000

376 Pine Hill Road, Salem, NY
Listing Agent: Star Schmaler

Have you ever dreamed of living in a tree house with amazing views?

 

Size: 1,585 sf

 

Price: $249,000

 

Listing details: Come see this treasure nestled on a mountainside in beautiful Hebron. Mountain views from every bedroom!

 

Contact: Star Schmaler, Coldwell Banker, +1 413.281.3988

13 Avery Ave | $187,500

13 Avery Ave, Alexandria Bay, NY
Listing Agent: Nancy Calandra

This charming two-story home offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience near Alex Bay.

 

Size: 1,660 sf

 

Price: $187,500

 

Listing details: With a low-maintenance backyard, cozy front porch, 3 bedrooms, and 1.5 baths, it’s ideal for entertaining or relaxing. A great option for first-time buyers or a potential summer rental.

 

Contact: Nancy Calandra, Coldwell Banker, +1 315.271.1341

 

Listing Agent: Timothy Spooner

Stunningly Preserved early 1900’s Neoclassical situated on large half acre lot in the heart of a charming Village of Newark neighborhood. Coming through the grand entrance you will be taken back to the days of extravagance, surrounded by leaded and beveled glass , and jaw dropping woodwork throughout. No shortage of storage in this house . the custom kitchen with extra tall uppers, and quartz counters.

 

Size: 4,562 sf

 

Price: $384,900

 

Listing details: Walk-in pantry with floor to ceiling built-ins, as well as built-ins in the upstairs hallway and primary suite. Sunroom on the first and second floor primary suite sunroom provide more quiet areas to relax. Enjoy the private backyard and large side yard for entertaining with plenty of room for parking Centrally located to the Finger Lakes, Rochester and Lake Ontario.

 

Contact: Timothy Spooner, Sotheby`s Realty, +1 585.455.0625