10 Properties for Sale Under $500k in Indiana & Michigan

Discover your dream home or the perfect lot opportunity – all without breaking the bank. Explore ten stunning properties in Indiana and Michigan, all priced under $500K, offering you exceptional value and charm.

Westside Stunner | $455,000

745 Garrison Ln, Indianapolis, IN
Listing agent: Rew Van Wyck & Greg Mayo

Westside stunner with 5 bedrooms, 3 1/2 baths, beautifully updated kitchen and open dining family area, dedicated dining room and finished full size basement. Beautiful decor throughout with many upgrades.


Size: 3,295 sf


Price: $455,000


Listing details: There is an attached 3 car garage with Tesla charger. Exterior shows a completely manicured landscape with back privacy fence and deck…and all in the Avon School System.


Contact: Rew Van Wyck & Greg Mayo, High Garden Real Estate, +1 317.709.5027, 317.370.2847

1225 W 33rd Street | $12,900

1225 W 33rd Street, Indianapolis, IN
Listing agent: Lincoln Gardner

35 x 145, buildable, vacant lot. All utilities available for future connection. Conveniently located in the emerging Riverside Neighborhood just minutes from downtown.


Size: 5,227.20 sf


Price: $12,900


Listing details: Prime location about a mile from the recently-updated Riverside city park & South Grove Golf Course.


Contact: Lincoln Gardner, Alpine Realty LLC, +1 317.512.4109

2159 W 58th St | $385,000

2159 W 58th St, Indianapolis, IN
Listing agent: Gabriela Pitts

NEW!!! COMPLETE NEW CONSTRUCTION!! Welcome to this stunning ranch-style home located in the Northolm subdivision of Indianapolis. With 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, this beautifully designed property boasts a generous 2,038 square feet of living space. As you approach the home, you’ll be captivated by the expansive yard and convenient storage shed.


Size: 2,038 sf


Price: $385,000


Listing details: Step inside and be greeted by the exquisite bathrooms adorned with luxurious finishes. The kitchen dazzles with quartz counter tops and a fancy crystal glass back splash. Every room offers ample space, ensuring comfort and tranquility.


Contact: Gabriela Pitts, High Garden Real Estate, +1 317-494-1344

Comfort And Elegance Lake Home | $464,900

140 South, Wolcottville, IN
Listing agent: Emmon Schmucker

The All-Sport Whitmer Lake Home offers a harmonious blend of comfort and elegance, with its open concept design and modern amenities. The newly remodeled kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining area and living room, creating an inviting space for entertainment and relaxation.


Size: 1,480 sf


Price: $464,900


Listing details: The property boasts a significant channel frontage and a robust concrete sea wall, ensuring a private and serene lakeside experience. With ample parking and a spacious two-car garage, this home is an ideal retreat for hosting summer gatherings and creating lasting memories by the water.


Contact: Emmon Schmucker, Coldwell Banker, +1 574.202.3800

355 E Ohio St #105 | $384,500

355 E Ohio St #105, Indianapolis, IN
Listing agent: Jodie Klain Balber

Located in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis, this luxury condo is up-to-date and move-in ready, with hardwood floors, granite counter tops, crown molding, high ceilings, gas fireplace, stainless steel appliances, California Closets and storage, Jacuzzi whirlpool bathtub, and brand new HVAC system.


Size: 1,253 sf


Price: $384,500


Listing details: The flowing open floor plan, natural light, and East facing private balcony allows for greenery views and sunsets of lively downtown Indianapolis. Secure building entrance and attached heated parking garage. Ideally located next door to Whole Foods and Tinker Street Coffee with future developments planned in all directions, and just a few blocks from Monument Circle, Mass Ave, and so much more.


Contact: Jodie Klain Balber, ALO Property Group, +1 317.281.8846

Style And Comfort | $369,900

522 E Minnesota Street, Indianapolis, IN
Listing agent: Monica Scheker

Beautifully landscaped surroundings ready to welcome you. Explore not just one…. but two primary master suits loaded with spa like bathrooms that are sure to impress! Entire home has been thoughtfully redone along with brand new addition to the existing home creating a very nice layout with high ceilings through out creating an upscale living environment!


Size: 1,872 sf


Price: $369,900


Listing details: Enjoy your private backyard space with new custom fence. Elevate your lifestyle to new heights with this exceptional property!


Contact: Monica Scheker, Keller Williams, +1 317-619-4540

Home Sweet Home | $475,000

10924 Braewick Drive, Carmel, IN
Listing agent: Christine Jones

Stunning Curb-Appeal invites you into this 4-Bedroom, 2.5 Bath, 2.5 Car-Finished Garage, Custom- Built Brick Home in “The Woodlands”! Professionally landscaped on nearly 1/2 Acre of lush green grass, flower beds and mature trees. The custom deck completes your magnificent backyard, featuring; built in seating, vibrant cushions and separate dining area.


Size: 3,858 sf


Price: $475,000


Listing details: The entire home has been professionally painted with pleasing Pottery Barn tones. As you enter you will feel welcomed by the beautiful entry and custom tile flooring. The Formal Living with Custom Plantation Shutters and Gleaming Hardwood Floors flows into the beautiful Formal Dining Room.


Contact: Christine Jones, Talk to Tucker Realtors, +1 317.626.1999

Build Your Luxury Dream Home | $425,000

1436 Park West Cir, Munster, IN
Listing agent: Ricardo Martinez

Build your luxury dream home on this half acre piece of land located in the desirable Park West! This is an ideal location and upscale gated community.


Size: 0.52 acres


Price: $425,000


Listing details: Located just 30 miles from Chicago and close to shopping, dining, highways, and more!


Contact: Ricardo Martinez, Listing Leaders, +1 312.856.5155

0000 Joseph Rd | $160,000

0000 Joseph Rd, Vandalia, MI
Listing agent: WAYNE RYAN

Undeveloped vacant lot over 1/2 acre with 150’ of channel frontage to all sports Shavehead Lake.


Size: 0.54 acres


Price: $160,000


Listing details: Electric & Porter Twp. sewer district tap are accessible at street. Build your dream home or family compound here.


Contact: WAYNE RYAN, Indiana Regional MLS, +1 574.876.9641

A Lake House On Fish Lake | $269,000

63899 Lakeshore Rd, Sturgis, MI
Listing agent: Angela Pritchard

Who wants a Lake House on Fish Lake? This home offers 3 bedrooms and 1 bath. Finished basement with a possible 4th bedroom in the basement. There is also an over sized 40 x 24 2 stall garage with the home positioned on a double lot.


Size: 2,000 sf


Price: $269,000


Listing details: New roof in 2020 on the garage and house. New windows 2011, Generac generator 2020. High efficiency furniture and condenser. New poured driveway. 12 x 24 shed was added in 2021.


Contact: Angela Pritchard, Front Door Real Estate, +1 574-993-2906